Don’t Call Them Prawn: District 9 Review

By Sarah • Aug 24th, 2009 • Category: Dr. Thompson's Motivational Posters, Reviews

District 9

There were so many ways District 9 could have gone wrong. It has a director and cast nobody’s heard of, it relies heavily on special effects and spectacle yet had a (by Hollywood standards) meager budget. It shifts narrative style back and forth between pseudo-documentary and cinematic. It throws a handful of genres – sci-fi thriller, action, political commentary and love story – into a blender and pours it all out. And the end result? One of the most gripping and imaginative movies I’ve seen in years.

TV director Neil Blomkamp’s tale opens with what feels like a History Channel episode, revealing via interviews and “file footage” that a mothership full of buglike alien drones landed over Johannesburg, South Africa 20 years ago. With their leaders mysteriously vanished and no apparent means of getting their ship mobile again, the creatures were “welcomed” to earth and assigned living quarters in the area below their ship, referred to as District 9. The creatures possessed a substantial arsenal of weapons only they could operate, yet had little interest in using other than to trade for food. Disliked and exploited by the locals and the government, the aliens have spent the last two decades living as scavengers and District 9 is a miserable ghetto. Now, the government (or more specifically the government branch MNU – Multi National Union) is setting out to remove the creatures from the city into District 10, a camp-like area (note the use of the word “camp”.) Placed in charge of this massive eviction is MNU agent Wykum van de Merwe, who’s pretty much the walking definition of “stooge.” Halfway through his first day on the job, he encounters Christopher, a creature who is sharper and less compliant than the others. Inside Christopher’s shack Wykum discovers an array of handbuilt computers and what looks like a chemistry set. From there, things begin to go down hill.

D9 has plenty going for it but its two biggest assets lie in the portrayal of the main characters, Wykum and Christopher. Sharlto Copley, in his first major picture, plays Wykum with amazing conviction, and he doesn’t shy away from the character’s substantial flaws. One minute you want to punch him in the face, the next, you’re holding your breath hoping he’ll survive. And Christopher is so endearing a character, and so realistically rendered, the fact that he’s completely a CGI creation doesn’t even register. The villains (and there are a lot of them) don’t fare quite as well. Though well-acted, they are all almost cartoonishly one-dimensional, and it’s a jarring contrast to the complex, strongly developed characters of Christopher and Wykum. That’s the only major criticism I have. D9 looks gorgeous, the entire cast is excellent and the story, while simple, isn’t dumbed down. I definitely want to see more from Blomkamp, whether it’s District 10 or something else entirely.

9/10

Share this little slice of awesomeness




Do you want that totally awesome avatar to show up next to your name? Of course you do. The Dirty Sprocket Blog uses Gravatar for all our avatar needs. Click here to sign up for your very own Gravatar and it will show up next to your comments.

3 Comments

  • On August 24 09, Monte said:

    Can’t wait to see it.

    • On September 9 09, D9 sux said:

      D9 is a big failure!!!

      First, we are intelligent people, we expect to have something more than just aliens are getting fucked and owned by humans in a movie.
      How could aliens who came all this way to Earth being controlled by a bunch of Nigerians? Because of illness? that’s too BS for a reason, especially in a movie! At least spend 2 minutes explain how they can’t fight against humans!!

      Also, they can fire their weapons, why do they rely on treading with the Nigerians? They don’t have some random 1ml fluid fuel to get back? WOW, it gotta be the worse movie ever.

      Then turning aliens into “native like” people or ghetto living prawn is not very fascinating.

      this entire movie is just about how rich people torture the poor folks, but instead of using humans as the enemy, they use aliens.

      Also at the end… They make this stupid government employee into a prawn, it quite “make sense”… At lease give the audience more information about how did he turn into a prawn, maybe all the “prawns” are being infected by the virus, maybe they are not aliens, that’s why christopher didn’t take them with him??

      It’s just bad …

      • On September 10 09, Derek said:

        I think you raise some very valid points about the movie. I think it did have flaws, several of which you mention, but it is one of those movies I was able to get past my little issues with the movie and thoroughly enjoy the thing. Ultimately even with my issues this is one of my favorite movies of the year. Again, you do bring up some good points.

      (Required)
      (Required, will not be published)



      Who the hell is this guy (or gal) anyway?

      Sarah is pretty damn cool. Sarah DeVries was born in Pierre in 1980. She's lived in South Dakota most of her life and in the Black Hills for five years. She's known Derek for about two years helped out on Scattering Tarnak the Great, mostly with the boom. She works at Golden West and likes writing in her spare time (hence the attachment to Dirty Sprocket). She has one cat, one fish and no children and plans on keeping it that way. Favorite movie: Reservoir Dogs Favorite show: Mystery Science Theater 3000 Favorite book: Jane Eyre Favorite drink: amaretto & Coke
      Email this author | All posts by Sarah